Holiday gift advice needed! Wine Preservation Device or Essences/Aroma Kit?

[Bucko]

I hope I can help. I don't really find the commercial wine savers practical for home use. Buy him a case of Private Preserve, which will help keep hundreds of bottles fresh and is easy to use.

As far as the scents kit, go for the real thing if you are going to buy one. I used this kit to "study" for the California wine judges test many moons ago:

Le Nez du Vin Master Kit
Le Nez du Vin, The Faults of Wine Kit

Good luck on your search.