are these good suggestions

[nicolem]

I'm purchasing a few bottles for a collection I am starting as a gift for my fiance, for future consumption.

This is what someone from Pops wines suggested
what do you experts think

California Cabernets 1997 for the 10-15 year Airwood
Judd's Hill
Newton

and some chardonnay for 2-3 year
Vine Cliff reserve
Farni Niente
all in the $50 per bottle range

[winoweenie]

Nicolem,All of the reds suggested are superb wines. The Arrowood ,Judds, and Newton all reside in my-very-own cellar. You'll have to get the info on the SW's from some-un else. WW