Seeking comments on first bottle of wine

[Tyrrell]

I have a question

While I see the value in the posts that WW, Stevebody, and Foodie responded with, I am curious about why none of the three of you did not also give some information that pertained (albeit peripherally) to the question.

Would the descriptions of what other people tasted in this wine (such as descriptions of aromas, body, tannin, length, etc.) have been somehow harmful to the poster's development as a wine consumer? Or was it merely that none of you had the information on hand?




[This message has been edited by Tyrrell (edited 06-09-2003).]