Thoughts on these?

[bkadue]

I asked a guy I work with who's somewhat into wines to choose a few that he likes from the sale flyer at my local store.

My plan is starting this December, I'm going to buy a case of 5 different wines. That's more than I'll drink in 2012, and I'll do the same at the end of 2012. After ~5 years, I should have a pretty solid collection of wines, some of which will have been aged a few years to boot.

If YOU were executing MY plan, are there any selections below that stand out to you as good wines/values or bad?

I'd appreciate any thoughts from the experts on any of these choices. As you can see, I'm looking at $10 or under:

Chateau Le Gay Bordeaux 2009 $9.99
Mouton Cadet Red $5.99
Chateau Cadillac Blanc $9.99
Cotes du Rhone Bernard Chartreuse de Bonpas $10.99
Davinci Pinot Grigio $8.99
Cristalino Brut N/V $6.99
Columbia Crest Grand Estate Cab $7.99
Coumbia Crest 2-Vines Cab $5.99
Chateu Ste Michelle Chardonnay $7.99
Dam Red Merlot and Cab $9.99
Menage a Trois Red $7.99
Marcus James Malbec $3.99
Penfolds Koonuga Hills Shiraz/Cab $7.99