+- WineBoard (https://www.wines.com/wineboard)
+-- Forum: RESOURCES AND OTHER STUFF (https://www.wines.com/wineboard/forum-300.html)
+--- Forum: Home Winemaking (https://www.wines.com/wineboard/forum-39.html)
+--- Thread: sulfites in wine (/thread-15104.html)
- danbaum - 01-31-1999
I am a beginning winemaker and am confursed with the difference between sodium and potasium metabisulfite. Which one should be used at bottling and why?
- Jerry D Mead - 02-01-1999
Dan...I got an e-mail response for you from the winemaker for Smith & Hook and Hahn Estate...have asked a couple of others to look in here and comment on your question. In the meantime:
Sodium is not permitted any more but is a lot easier to use than the
potassium form. This chap can write me and I'd be glad to help him. ART
His e-mail address is: artnathan@prodigy.net
How's that for service?
JDM
- Dick Peterson - 02-14-1999
For the home winemaker there is no reason to worry about whether Sodium or Potassium is the preferred legal entity to use. Both are completely safe and the reason Potassium is preferred is that wine is considered to be a low sodium food. Avoiding the addition of any sodium salt keeps it that way. But the amount of sodium in the few ppm of sodium bisulfite you'll add is probably always inconsequential. Sodium is cheaper and won't screw up the stability of the wine if you add it. Potassium is much more expensive and, if a lot is added, can (at least in theory) cause a stable wine to become cold unstable. After adding a potassium salt like metabisulfite you'd have to re-chill the wine to get the extra potassium bitartrate to drop out and make the wine stable again. As a practical matter, you're not likely to add enough potassium metabisulfite to cause stability problems. Similarly, if you add sodium bisulfite, you're not likely to add enough sodium to make any difference to the low sodium status of your wine. All in all, I think you should use the cheapest and easiest (namely, sodium bisulfite) for your wine. Be sure to calculate the amount of actual SO2 and not the total salt you're adding. Hope this helps. Dick Peterson
- Jerry D Mead - 02-14-1999
For those who don't recognize the name...our friend just received advice from one of America's most highly regarded winemakers. His profile humbly lists him as "enologist." Not untrue, but this enologist worked in research at Gallo, alongside the late Andre Tchelistcheff at Beaulieu, was founding partner and winemaker at The Monterey Vineyard, ditto for Atlas Peak and is now a major partner in Napa's Folie a Deux...and I've probably left out a bunch of stuff.
Thanks, Dick! JDM
PS He writes the technical column for Wines & Vines magazine!
[This message has been edited by Wine Curmudgeon (edited 02-14-99).]